Operation Twist is a monetary policy term often use in discussions about finance and economic strategies. Originating as a policy tool employed by the Federal Reserve, Operation Twist aims to influence interest rates and stimulate economic growth without increasing the money supply.

But what exactly is Operation Twist, and why does it matter? This article discusses briefly its origin, mechanics, impact, and examples, providing a comprehensive understanding of this unique monetary policy.

Operation Twist’s History and Origin

In order to boost cash inflows into the economy and strengthen the US dollar (USD), the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) launched the first “Operation Twist” in 1961.

The nation was still getting out of the recession that had followed the end of the Korean War at this point. The yield curve was flattened by selling short-term government debt in the markets and using the proceeds to buy long-term government debt in order to encourage economic spending.

Operation Twist first emerged under the Kennedy administration. The term “twist” refers to the deliberate attempt to twist the yield curve—a graphical representation of bond yields across different maturities—by selling short-term government securities and buying long-term ones. The Federal Reserve and the U.S. Treasury designed this strategy to achieve two primary goals, which are:

• Lower long-term interest rates to encourage investments in housing and business expansion.
• Prevent capital outflows by maintaining higher short-term interest rates.

The name derives from the “twist” effect on the yield curve: flattening the longer end while keeping the shorter end stable.

How Does Operation Twist Work?

Operation Twist involves strategic bond transactions to influence interest rates without altering the total money supply. Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of its mechanics:

• Selling Short-Term Bonds: The central bank sells short-term government bonds to reduce their prices and increase their yields. Higher short-term yields attract foreign investments and stabilize the currency.
• Buying Long-Term Bonds: Simultaneously, the central bank purchases long-term government bonds, increasing their prices and lowering their yields. Lower long-term yields reduce borrowing costs for businesses and individuals.
• Twisting the Yield Curve: By increasing short-term yields and decreasing long-term yields, the policy creates a more favorable environment for economic growth.

This targeted approach distinguishes Operation Twist from other monetary policies, such as quantitative easing, which directly increases the money supply.

The Impact of Operation Twist

Operation Twist can significantly influence various economic factors, including:

1. Interest Rates: By lowering long-term interest rates, the policy reduces borrowing costs for mortgages, student loans, and corporate debt.
2. Economic Growth: Encouraging investment and spending can boost economic activity, particularly during periods of stagnation.
3. Monetary Policy Flexibility: It allows central banks to influence the economy without resorting to printing more money, thereby minimizing inflation risks.

 Operation Twist Example

• 1961 Initiative: The Federal Reserve’s initial implementation aimed to counterbalance a slowing economy and a growing trade deficit. While its success was mixed, it paved the way for future experiments. 
• 2011 Revival:Since short-term rates were already at zero in 2011, the Fed was unable to lower them any more. Lowering long-term interest rates was then the alternative. The Fed accomplished this by purchasing long-term Treasuries and selling short-term Treasury securities, which pushed the yields on long-term bonds lower and stimulated the economy.The Fed would purchase longer-term Treasury notes (T-notes) and bonds with the proceeds from the maturation of short-term Treasury Bills (T-Bills) and notes. Since the Fed had promised to maintain short-term interest rates close to zero for the ensuing two years, the impact on short-term rates was negligible.The yield on 10-year T-notes, the benchmark bond for interest rates on all fixed-rate loans, was only roughly 1.95% throughout this period, while the yield on 2-year bonds was nearly zero.3.

  Both individuals and corporations can borrow money more cheaply as interest rates decline. When these organizations can obtain loans at cheap interest rates, firms can more easily obtain funds to expand and finance their initiatives, which boosts economic expenditure and lowers unemployment.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Operation Twist

Some of the notable advantages are:

• Reducing long-term borrowing costs without increasing the money supply.
• Helping to stabilize the economy during financial downturns.
• It offers a targeted approach compared to broader monetary policies.

Disadvantages include:

• Limited effectiveness in addressing deep economic recessions.
• Potential distortion of financial markets.
• Dependence on investor confidence for success.

How Does It Compare to Other Monetary Policies?

Quantitative Easing (QE): Unlike Operation Twist, QE involves purchasing government bonds across all maturities and expanding the money supply. While QE is more aggressive, it carries higher risks of inflation.

Traditional Interest Rate Adjustments: Lowering or raising interest rates directly influences borrowing costs. Operation Twist, on the other hand, indirectly affects rates by targeting bond yields.

Issues with Operation Twist

Despite its potential benefits, Operation Twist has faced criticism such as:

• Mixed Results: Empirical evidence on its effectiveness remains inconclusive.
• Market Distortion: Frequent bond market interventions can disrupt natural price discovery.
• Short-Term Focus: Its impact is often temporary, requiring complementary policies for long-term solutions.

Conclusion:

The Federal Reserve uses Operation Twist, an unorthodox monetary policy instrument, to boost economic expansion and preserve price stability. The Fed can reduce long-term interest rates without growing its balance sheet by exchanging short-term Treasury securities for long-term ones.

Although the effectiveness of it is still up for question, the Federal Reserve has previously employed it as a weapon to boost the economy and may do so again in the future.

Related Article

Yield Chasing

yield curve

Inverted Yield Curve

Bond

Bond Yields