Settlement risk, also known as delivery risk or Herstatt risk, is the chance that one party in a financial transaction fails to deliver their promised payment or asset. This risk is particularly significant in forex trading, where two parties exchange different currencies at different times.
For example, a trader in the U.S. sends U.S. dollars to a European trader expecting euros in return. If the European trader defaults before sending the euros, the U.S. trader suffers a loss.
This type of risk became widely recognized after the 1974 collapse of Bankhaus Herstatt, where traders lost millions due to failed settlements.
Settlement risk is, in theory, just the possibility that one party will not fulfil their end of the bargain. Anybody who purchases anything online runs the risk of it arriving late or never at all. This risk is very similar to settlement risk in securities markets.
In This Post
Why Does Settlement Risk Matter in Forex?
delivery risk can cause substantial financial losses and disrupt global markets. Since forex trading involves multiple time zones, delays in settlement increase the possibility of one party failing to fulfill its obligations. In April 2022, around $2.2 trillion in daily forex transactions were exposed to settlement risk, showing its massive impact.
If a major financial institution defaults, the ripple effect can cause severe liquidity shortages and impact currency exchange rates worldwide. This is why traders and institutions must take steps to mitigate settlement risk.
Types of Settlement Risk
Pre-Settlement Risk
This occurs when a counterparty defaults before the transaction’s completion, often due to insolvency or financial distress.
Settlement Risk
This happens when one party has already delivered their asset or payment, but the counterparty fails to deliver in return.
Temporal Risk
This arises due to time-zone differences. For instance, in forex markets, one party may release funds during its working hours, but the counterparty, located in a different time zone, may default by the time it’s their working hours.
Systemic Risk
If a major institution defaults, it can create a chain reaction, affecting other institutions as well.
Operational Risk
This is associated with procedural errors, system failures, or other operational issues that can prevent the successful settlement of a transaction.
Liquidity Risk
If one party defaults, the other might face a liquidity crunch, unable to access the funds or assets they were expecting.
How to Reduce Settlement Risk in Forex
To protect against settlement risk, traders and financial institutions use various strategies, including:
Payment vs. Payment (PvP) Systems
These ensure that currency transfers happen simultaneously, reducing the risk of one party defaulting.
Continuous Linked Settlement (CLS)
CLS is a global network that settles forex transactions by linking payments in real time, minimizing risk.
Netting Agreements
These agreements allow counterparties to offset payments, reducing the total amount at risk.
Collateralization
Traders require counterparties to provide collateral to cover potential losses in case of default.
By using these methods, forex traders can lower their exposure to delivery risk and protect their investments.
Examples of Settlement Risk
Forex Transactions
Take the example of a US company purchasing Japanese goods. They agreed to pay in yen, and the Japanese business promised to deliver the goods as soon as they got the money.
The Japanese bank fails to transfer the goods in the evening (Japan time) because of a banking crisis in Japan, while the US company transfers the Yen in the morning (US time). The US company is now exposed to delivery risk.
Stock Market Trades
Grace agrees to buy 100 shares of Company X from Dan. Grace transfers the money to Dan, expecting to receive the shares in return.
However, due to an operational glitch, Dan’s broker fails to transfer the shares to Grace. Grace has now paid money but hasn’t received the shares, exposing her to delivery risk.
Regulatory Measures and Best Practices
Regulators worldwide emphasize proper risk management to prevent financial disruptions. Institutions like the European Central Bank and the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) set guidelines for banks to follow, ensuring safer forex transactions.
Best practices include:
- Conducting thorough counterparty risk assessments
- Using automated risk management tools
- Diversifying trading partners to avoid overexposure to a single entity
By following these measures, forex traders and institutions can enhance their security and maintain smooth trading operations.
Final Thoughts
Delivery risk is a major concern in forex trading, but with the right strategies, traders can minimize its impact.
Using secure settlement systems, implementing risk management techniques, and following regulatory guidelines are crucial for maintaining a stable and profitable trading environment.
By understanding and addressing this, traders can trade with confidence and reduce potential losses.
Related Term
Reach us on WhatsApp
